Educational Transformation During the Political Revolution: Restructuring the Education System in Early Republican China (1912-1916)
Author: Yu-Wen Chou (Department of Education, National Taiwan Normal University)6
Vol.&No.:Vol. 68, No. 4
Date:December 2023
Pages:67-93
DOI:https://doi.org/10.6209/JORIES.202312_68(4).0003
Abstract:
The state of education during tumultuous times has often been overlooked by educational historians. However, such periods warrant attention because educational opportunities can be severely limited during these times. The fall of the Ch’ing dynasty in October 1911 led to the establishment of the Republic of China. Although a provisional Republican government was inaugurated in Nanking on January 1, 1912, the new democracy remained divided. A new Ministry of Education was established, and Dr. Yuan-Pei Tsai became its first minister. Tsai endeavored to replace the Ch’ing dynasty’s existing K’uei Mao School System, instituted in 1904, with a new educational framework for the Republic. Because the government urgently wished to resume academic sessions by March of that year, a provisional general education regulation was promulgated through telegrams by the new ministry. The Republic was forced to adapt the Chi’ing dynasty’s educational system, implementing emergency modifications such as renaming schools and principals, implementing a two-semester academic year, permitting coeducation in primary schools, removing the distinction between general and vocational secondary schools, revising primary and secondary school textbooks, and shortening the duration of secondary and normal school to 4 years. The effectiveness of the new regulations remained unclear because of ongoing conflicts between China’s southern and northern governments.
Reconciliation between the two factions led to superficial national unity in April. Subsequently, the Ministry of Education convened the Provisional Education Meeting in Peking, the new capital, in July 1912. President Shih-Kai Yuan announced new educational objectives and a reformed school system in early September, 2 months after the meeting. The revised educational goals emphasized moral, military and national, and aesthetic education. The new system comprised five educational stages: 4-year junior elementary school, 3-year senior elementary school, 4-year secondary school, 3-year prep-school, and 4-year university. This structure, although similar to the Ch’ing dynasty 4-5-4-3-3-4 model, had been streamlined to a 4-3-4-3-4 model; completing one’s education from elementary school through university required a minimum of 18 years. A series of educational codes, regulations, and curricula were systematically introduced between 1912 and 1913, culminating in the establishment of the Jen Tzu K’uei Ch’ou School System.
Regarding the historical narrative of educational reforms in early Republican China, the literature provides only a cursory overview of the new system; it does not delve into the complexities of the reform process or offer critical commentary. Employing a historical method, this study usedfirst-hand sources, including documents from government archives, statutes, regulations, official gazettes, journals, and newspapers. This study employed both internal and external criticism to explore how the new central government sought to reconstruct China’s educational system between 1912 and 1916; to analyze the causes, process, practices, and factors influencing these educational reforms; and to draw conclusions and implications. The major findings are as follows.
The primary motivations for reforming the Ch’ing dynasty’s educational system included its inefficiency, shortcomings, excessively long duration, improper curricula, and inconsistencies or redundancies across educational levels.
Empirical evidence indicates that only 6 out of 18 provincial governments adopted the new statutes and regulations to implement the new educational system; the status of the remaining provinces remains unknown. Four major factors influenced these reforms. First, the Ch’ing school system, which was modeled after the Japanese system, continued to exert a considerable influence. Although the number of students who had graduated from Western countries increased after 1912, most had not focused on educational studies and consequently had limited understanding of Western educational systems. Second, ongoing political turmoil from 1913 to 1916, involving the rapid failure of the Second Revolution, the dissolution of China’s parliament, the abolition of the constitution, the ascent and rapid descent of President Yuan as Emperor, the fleeting restoration of the Ch’ing dynasty, and the outbreak of civil wars among various warlords, severely hampered reform efforts. Third, the financial resources allocated to education by local governments were consistently inadequate, primarily due to the diversion of educational funds to military activities. In addition, the limited educational funds were often squandered by local educational agencies and schools. Finally, administrative disorganization and power struggles among provincial, local, and central governments negatively affected the implementation of the new system.
The lessons from China’s modern history indicate that completely abolishing an existing educational system is not strategically necessary for a new regime. In China, some revisions were made, and the old system continued to function.
In understanding these reforms, consideration must be given to the fact that numerous provincial and central government officials visited Japan to gain educational insights after 1894. Additionally, a substantial number of Chinese students were studying in Japan at that time. These factors may have influenced the subsequent introduction of the Japanese education model into China. In the development of comparative education, modern China transitioned from what can be termed the “traveler’s tale” stage to a stage of “educational borrowing.”
A comparison of the number of Chinese students studying in Japan and the US between 1906 and 1912 revealed that more students were in Japan. Moreover, these students displayed a deeper understanding of the educational system they were immersed in. During the Provisional Education Meeting of 1912, the participants who had received Japanese education outnumbered those of US and therefore likely had a greater influence on the final decisions. Notably, Hsi-Kuang Yau and Yi Chen, who were sent by Hu-Kuang Governor-General Chih-Tung Chang to inspect Japanese education in the late Ch’ing dynasty, played influential roles. Chen had even translated Japanese educational laws and drafted a framework for the K’uei Mao School System. Both individuals were official delegates, and therefore, their influence was substantial.
Since 1922, the educational system established between 1912 and 1913 has been replaced by what is known as the New School System, which was modeled after the US 6-3-3-4 educational structure.
In conclusion, the educational reforms of early Republican China offer valuable lessons for modern educational reformers. Adopting an evolutionary strategy rather than a revolutionary one, China reformed its education system during a period of political instability. Modern China’s experience serves as an insightful case study for those considering revolutionary strategies for educational reform in the future.
Keywords:early Republican China, political revolution, educational reform, educational aim,school system
《Full Text》
References:
- 大都督訓令第39號(1912)。秦中公報,250,31-32。【Governor Circular 39 (1912). Shansi Gazette, 250, 31-32.】
- 文啟(編)(2006a)。中國近代教育史料匯編(民國卷)1。全國圖書館文獻縮微複製中心。【Wen, Q. (Ed.). (2006a). Collected sources of modern history of Chinese education: Republic of China I. China National China Microfilming Center for Library Resources.】
- 文啟(編)(2006b)。中國近代教育史料匯編(民國卷)2。全國圖書館文獻縮微複製中心。【Wen, Q. (Ed.). (2006b). Collected sources of modern history of Chinese education: Republic of China II. China National China Microfilming Center for Library Resources.】
- 文牘(1912)。通告各市鄉公所學校文。寶山共和雜誌,3,60-62。【Documents (1912). Notice to schools in cities and townships. Bao shan Republic Magazine, 3, 60-62.】
- 文牘(1913)。都督兼民政長布告各學校明定教育宗旨文。廣東教育公報,1(12),584-586。【Documents (1913). Governor announcement on the educational objectives to schools. Kwangtung Education Gazette, 1(12), 584-586.】
» More
- 大都督訓令第39號(1912)。秦中公報,250,31-32。【Governor Circular 39 (1912). Shansi Gazette, 250, 31-32.】
- 文啟(編)(2006a)。中國近代教育史料匯編(民國卷)1。全國圖書館文獻縮微複製中心。【Wen, Q. (Ed.). (2006a). Collected sources of modern history of Chinese education: Republic of China I. China National China Microfilming Center for Library Resources.】
- 文啟(編)(2006b)。中國近代教育史料匯編(民國卷)2。全國圖書館文獻縮微複製中心。【Wen, Q. (Ed.). (2006b). Collected sources of modern history of Chinese education: Republic of China II. China National China Microfilming Center for Library Resources.】
- 文牘(1912)。通告各市鄉公所學校文。寶山共和雜誌,3,60-62。【Documents (1912). Notice to schools in cities and townships. Bao shan Republic Magazine, 3, 60-62.】
- 文牘(1913)。都督兼民政長布告各學校明定教育宗旨文。廣東教育公報,1(12),584-586。【Documents (1913). Governor announcement on the educational objectives to schools. Kwangtung Education Gazette, 1(12), 584-586.】
- 中國第二歷史檔案館(編)(1991)。中華民國檔案資料匯編:第三輯教育。江蘇古籍。【The Second Historical Archives of China. (Ed.). (1991). Collected archives of Republic of China: III education. Jiangsu Guji.】
- 中國第二歷史檔案館(編)(2010a)。北洋政府檔案(089)。中國檔案。【The Second Historical Archives of China. (Ed.). (2010a). Beiyang government archives (089). China Archives Press.】
- 中國第二歷史檔案館(編)(2010b)。北洋政府檔案(091)。中國檔案。【The Second Historical Archives of China. (Ed.). (2010b). Beiyang government archives (091). China Archives Press.】
- 王炳照(編)(1994)。中國近代教育史。五南。【Wang, B.-Z. (Ed.). (1994). Modern history of Chinese education. Wu-Nan Book.】
- 田正平、李笑賢(編)(2018)。黃炎培教育論著選。人民教育。【Tien, Z.-P., & Li, X.-X. (Eds.). (2018). Selected works of Huang Yanpei on education. People Education.】
- 朱有瓛、戚名琇、錢曼倩、霍益萍(編)(2007)。中國近代教育史資料匯編:教育行政機構及教育團體。上海教育。【Zu, Y.-H., Qi, M.-S., Qian, M.-Q., & Huo, Y.-P. (Eds.). (2007). Collected sources of history of education in modern China: Educationaladministration agencies and educational societies. Shanghai Education.】
- 李桂林、戚名琇、錢曼倩(編)(1995)。中國近代教育史資料匯編:普通教育。上海教育。【Li, G.-L., Qi, M.-S., & Qian, M.-Q. (Eds.). (1995). Collected sources of history of education in modern China: General education. Shanghai Education.】
- 李熙(1967)。政和縣志。成文。【Lee, H. (1967). Chengho countygazette. Chengwen.】
- 李興華(1997)。民國教育史。上海教育。【Li, S.-H. (1997). History of education in Republic of China. Shanghai Education.】
- 近代史教學研討會(1975)。中國近代史。幼獅。【Seminar of Modern History. (1975). Modern history of China. Youth.】
- 周愚文(2021a)。教育革命的挑戰:晚清西式初等教育制度建立與國民教育的醞釀。教育研究集刊,67(3),95-139。https://doi.org/10.3966/102887082021096703003【Chou, Y.-W. (2021a). Challenges to educational revolution: The establishment of western primary education in 1904 in Ch’ing China and the ferment of national education. Bulletin of Education Research, 67(3), 95-139. https://doi.org/10.3966/102887082021096703003】
- 周愚文(2021b)。晚清教育制度西化的前奏:癸卯學制頒行前西式教育的借入。臺灣師大出版社。【Chou, Y.-W. (2021b). The prelude of the westernization of education system inlate Ch’ing China the educational borrowing from the west before the enacting of Gui-Mao school system. National Taiwan Normal University Press.】
- 周愚文(2021c)。教育革命的地方史視角:晚清江蘇初等教育推動的探討。載於中國教育學會(編),預見教育2030—風險時代:教育價值、反思與行動(頁155-193)。學富。【Chou, Y.-W. (2021c). Education revolution from local history perspective: A review of promoting primary education in Kiangsu in late Ch’ing China. In China Education Society (Ed.), Envisioning education 2030: Educational value, reflection and action in the era of risk (pp. 155-193). Pro-ED.】
- 周愚文(2022a)。學制改革的地方視角:晚清癸卯學制實施後福建中小學教育的發展。教育研究集刊,68(3),39-77。https://doi.org/10.53106/102887082022096803002【Chou, Y.-W. (2022a). A local perspective of school system of reform: The development of primary and secondary education in Fukien since the enactment of Kuei-Mao school system in late Ch’ing China. Bulletin of Education Research, 68(3), 39-77. https://doi.org/10.53106/102887082022096803002】
- 周愚文(2022b)。教育體制改革下行政組織的轉型:晚清省級教育行政制度的再造。教育科學研究期刊,67(1),95-121。https://doi.org/10.6209/JORIES.202203_67(1).0004【Chou, Y.-W. (2022b). Transformation of educational administration as reforming educational system: Reconstructing provincial administration of education department in late Ch’ing China. Journal of Research in Educational Sciences, 67(1), 95-121. https://doi.org/10.6209/JORIES.202203_67(1).0004】
- 周愚文(2022c)。政治變動與教育新常態:民國初期政治動盪下地方教育行政制度的重建(1912-1925)。載於中國教育學會(編),創新變革與公平正義:新常態下的教育省思與行動(頁221-258)。學富。【Chou, Y.-W. (2022c). Political turmoil and new educational normality: The reconstruction of local educational administration systemin early Republican China (1912-1925). In China Education Society (Ed.), Educational innovation and equality: Reflections and actions in education under the new normal (pp. 221-258). Pro-ED.】
- 命令(1912)。教育部訓令第十號。浙江公報,307,8-10。【Order (1912). Ministry of education circular 10. Chekiang Gazette, 307, 8-10.】
- 法令(1912a)。教育雜誌,3(10),100-103。【Regulations (1912a). Education Journal, 3(10), 100-103.】
- 法令(1912b)。浙江軍政府公報,17,2-3。【Regulations (1912b). Chekiang Military Government Gazette, 17, 2-3.】
- 法令(1912c)。浙江軍政府公報,18,3-9。【Regulations (1912c). Chekiang Military Government Gazette, 18, 3-9.】
- 法令(1912d)。江蘇省公報,45,5-7。【Regulations (1912d). Kiangsu Province Gazette, 45, 5-7.】
- 法令(1912e)。教育部部令。直隸教育界,1,55-57。【Regulations (1912e). Ministry of education circulars. Chili Education, 1, 55-57.】
- 附錄(1912)。教育部擬議學校系統草案。教育雜誌,3(12),65-73。【Appendix (1912). School system drafted by ministry of education. Education Journal, 3(12), 65-73.】
- 省令(1912)。金華縣公報,1(1),3-5。【Province Orders (1912). Ch’inghwa County Gazette, 1(1), 3-5.】
- 要電(1912a)。福建公報,112,15-16。【Telegraphs (1912a). Fukien Gazette, 112, 15-16.】
- 要電(1912b)。福建公報,110,3。【Telegraphs (1912 b). Fukien Gazette, 110, 3.】
- 孫常煒(編著)(1984)。蔡元培先生年譜傳記(上冊)。國史館。【Sun, C.-W. (Ed.). (1984). Mr Yuan-Pei Tsai’s chronology and biography (I). Academica Historica.】
- 徐宗林、周愚文(2019)。教育史。五南。【Hsu, C.-L., & Chou, Y.-W. (2019). History of education. Wu-Nan Book.】
- 特別記事(1913)。中華民國元年教育大事記。中華教育界,1,1-3。【Special Events (1913). Educational events in the first year. Chinese Education, 1, 1-3.】
- 記事(1912)。教育雜誌,4(4),23。【Events (1912). Education Journal, 4(4), 23.】
- 高鳳謙(1912)。敬告教育部。教育雜誌,3(11),15-18。【Kau, F.-C. (1912). Advice to Ministry of Education. Education Journal, 3(11), 15-18.】
- 張廷玉(1982)。明史。鼎文。【Chang, T.-Y. (1982). Ming dynasty history. Tingwen.】
- 教育司令(1912)。湖南政報,1,9。【Department of Education Orders (1912). Hunan Gazette, 1, 9.】
- 教育部(編)(1985)。中華民國史建國史第一篇革命開國(二)。作者。【Ministry of Education. (Ed.). (1985). The establishment of history of Republic of China. Part I: Revolution and establishment (2). Author.】
- 教育部法令(1912a,4月7日)。四川都督府政報。【Ministry of Education Regulations (1912a, April 7). Szechwan Government Gazette.】
- 教育部法令(1912b,4月9日)。四川都督府政報。【Ministry of Education Regulations (1912b, April 9). Szechwan Government Gazette.】
- 教育類(1912)。教育司奉部電開設法收回教育財產等因通令遵照文。廣西公報,15,38。【Education Section (1912). Department of education notice on receiving educational properties according to ministry of education telegraph. Kwangs Gazette, 15, 38.】
- 清史稿校註編纂小組(1986)。清史稿校註。國史館。【Compilation Committee of Ch’ing History Draft Collation and Annotation. (1986). Ch’ing history draft collation and annotation. Academica Historica.】
- 莊俞(1912)。論教育方針。教育雜誌,4(1),1-11。【Chuang, Y. (1912). On education objectives. Education Journal, 4(1), 1-11.】
- 郭廷以(1980)。近代中國史綱。香港中文大學。【Kuo, T.-Y. (1980). Modern history of China. Hong Kong Chinese University.】
- 陳友松(2015)。中國教育財政之改進—關於其重建中主要問題的事實分析。商務。【Chen, Y.-S. (2015). The financing of the public education in China, a factual analysis its major problems of reconstruction. The Commercial Press.】
- 陳啟天(1962)。最近三十年中國教育史。文星。【Chen, C.-T. (1962). History of education within thirty years in China. Wenhsing.】
- 陳學恂(編)(1987)。中國近代教育史教學參考資料(中)。人民教育。【Chen, X.-X. (Ed.). (1987). Teaching sources of history of education in modern China, Book II. People Education.】
- 陳學恂、田正平(編)(1991)。中國近代教育史料匯編:留學教育。上海教育。【Chen, X.-X., & Tien, Z.-P. (Eds.). (1991). Collected sources of history of education in modern China: Study abroad. Shanghai Education.】
- 陸費逵(1912a)。敬告民國教育總長。教育雜誌,3(10),1-4。【Lu, F.-K. (1912a). Advice to ministry of education of China. Education Journal, 3(10), 1-4.】
- 陸費逵(1912b)。民國學制通議。教育雜誌,3(10),4-13。【Lu, F.-K. (1912b). On school system of Republic of China. Education Journal, 3(10), 4-13.】
- 舒新城(1989)。近代中國留學史。中華。【Shu, H.-C. (1989). History of Chinese study abroad. Chunghwa.】
- 舒新城(編)(1933)。近代中國教育史料(3版)。中華。【Shu, H.-C. (Ed.). (1933). Sources of history of education in modern China (3rd ed.). Chunghwa.】
- 舒新城(編)(1981)。中國近代教育史資料(2版)。人民教育。【Shu, H.-C. (Ed.). (1981). Sources of history of education in modern China (2nd ed.). People Education.】
- 詔令(1909)。南洋兵事雜志,29,1。【Regulations (1909). Southern China War affairs Magazine, 29, 1.】
- 越生文化(編)(2020a)。中國近代教育文獻叢刊‧教育法規卷12。浙江教育。【Yueseng Culture. (Ed.). (2020a). Collected documents of education in modern China: Education regulations 12. Chekiang Education.】
- 越生文化(編)(2020b)。中國近代教育文獻叢刊‧教育法規卷1。浙江教育。【Yueseng Culture. (Ed.). (2020b). Collected documents of education in modern China: Education regulations 1. Chekiang Education.】
- 馮象欽、劉欣森(編)(2008)。湖南教育史(二)。岳麓書社。【Feng, X.-Q., & Liu, X.-S. (Eds.). (2008). History of Hunan education (II). Yuelu.】
- 馮開文(1994)。中華民國教育史。人民。【Feng, K.-W. (1994). The history of education in Republic of China. People.】
- 董寶良(1990)。中國教育史綱(近代部份)。人民教育。【Dong, B.-L. (1990). Outline of history of education in China (modern). People Education.】
- 賈豐臻(1912)。今後之教育界。教育雜誌,4(6),115-126。【Chia, F.-C. (1912). Education in the future. Education Journal, 4(6), 115-126.】
- 賈豐臻(1914)。今後教育之希望。教育雜誌,5(11),129-132。【Chia, F.-C. (1914). The future of education. Education Journal, 5(11), 129-132.】
- 雷國鼎(1983)。中國近代教育行政制度史。教育文物。【Lei, K.-T. (1983). The history of educational administration in modern China. Education Facility.】
- 實藤惠秀(2012)。中國人留學日本史(譚汝謙、林啟彥,譯)。北京大學出版社。(原著出版於1960年)【Saneto, K. (2012). History of Chinese study in Japan (J.-Q. Tan & Q.-Y. Lin, Trans.). Peking University Press. (Original work published 1960)】
- 熊明安(1997)。中華民國教育史。重慶。【Xiong, A.-M. (1997). History of education in Republic of China. Chungching.】
- 劉超然(修)、鄭豐稔(纂)(1975)。崇安縣新志(一)。成文。【Liu, C.-J., & Cheng, F.-N. (Eds.). (1975). Chungan county new gazette (I). Chenwen.】
- 蔡元培(1912)。對新教育之意見。教育雜誌,3(11),1-11。【Tsai, Y.-P. (1912). Opinion on new education. Education Journal, 3(11), 1-11.】
- 鄭世興(1990)。中國現代教育史(2版)。三民。【Cheng, S.-H. (1990). History of education in modern China (2nd ed.). Sanmin.】
- 學部(1912a,3月31日)。學部呈河南河北中等農業學堂甲班補習生畢業請查照立案文。臨時公報(第二輯),19。江蘇廣陵古籍刻印社。【Ministry of Education. (1912a, March 31). A letter from Honan and Hopei secondary agriculture schools for approval of graduation of class A. Provisional Government Gazette II, 19. Jiangsu Guanglin Gujikeyin.】
- 學部(1912b,4月4日)。學部呈黑龍江西路初等商業等學堂畢業請查照備案文。臨時公報(第二輯),42。江蘇廣陵古籍刻印社。【Ministry of Education. (1912b, April 4). A letter from Heilungkiang west way junior commerce schools for approval of graduation. Provisional Government Gazette II, 42. Jiangsu Guanglin Gujikeyin.】
- 學部(1912c,4月16日)。學部呈吉林農業教員講習所簡易科畢業請查照備案文。臨時公報(第二輯),118。江蘇廣陵古籍刻印社。【Ministry of Education. (1912c, April 16). A letter from Chilin agriculture teacher seminary for approval of graduation of short-term program. Provisional Government Gazette II, 118. Jiangsu Guanglin Gujikeyin.】
- 學部(1980)。學部官報(第三冊)。國立故宮。【Ministry of Education. (1980). Ministry of education gazette III. National Palace Museum.】
- 學部總務司(編)(1986)。學部奏咨輯要。文海。(原著出版於1909年)【Ministry of Education General Affairs Department. (Ed.). (1986). The selected reports and orders of Ministry of Education. Wenhai. (Original work published 1909) 】
- 錢曼倩、金林祥(1996)。中國近代學制比較研究。廣東教育。【Qian, M.-Q., & Jin, L.-X. (1996). A comparison of school systems in modern China. Guangdong Education.】
- 璩鑫圭、唐良炎(編)(1991)。中國近代教育史資料匯編:學制演變。上海教育。【Cui, S.-G., & Tang, L.-Y. (Eds.). (1991). Collected sources of history of education in modern China: The change of school systems. Shanghai Education.】
- 蘇雲峰(2005)。中國新教育的芽與成長(1860-1928)。五南。【Su, Y.-F. (2005). The development of modern education in China (1860-1928). Wu-Nan Book.】