Application of a Teaching Capability Maturity Model and Fuzzy Analytic Hierarchy Process in Constructing Professionalism Indicators for Life Curriculum Teachers
Author: Yin-Che Chen (Department of Educational Psychology and Counseling, National Tsing Hua University), Mei-Yun Hu (San Min Primary School, Hsinchu City)
Vol.&No.：Vol. 64, No.1
Date：March 2019
Pages：1-24
DOI：10.6209/JORIES.201903_64(1).0001
Abstract：
Guidelines for a 12-year basic education curriculum were announced and implemented in Taiwan in 2014. In these guidelines, “life curriculum” is defined as a course that is designed to bridge the gap in elementary and kindergarten course knowledge for first and second graders. Teachers should demonstrate adequate professionalism to fully implement the core literacies embodying the curriculum ideas of the 12-year basic education curriculum. This study aimed to develop a set of indicators for the professionalism of life curriculum teachers. Literature on Taiwanese and international studies was first reviewed to establish criteria for the professionalism of life curriculum teachers. The teaching capability maturity model was adopted, which divides professionalism into five levels, namely the beginner level, basic curriculum management, advanced curriculum management and implementation, quantitative management, and sustainable optimization, and incorporates 15 dimensions and 45 indicator checkup items. A modified Delphi method was adopted to obtain consensus among experts and scholars. A fuzzy hierarchical analysis was performed to assign weights and ranks to the indicators at all five levels. This empirical indicator system was therefore developed to serve as a self-assessment tool for life curriculum teachers to develop their professionalism; moreover, the indicators may serve as a reference for educational administrative agencies to promote the development of teacher professionalism and support future teachers.
Keywords：fuzzy hierarchical analysis, life curriculum, modified Delphi method, teacher professionalism, teaching capability maturity model
《Full Text》
References：
- 丁增銓（2007）。由「教師專業」談「精進教學能力」。網路社會學通訊期刊，63，31-33。 【Ding, Z.-Q. (2007). Discussing “teaching skill improvement” through “teacher professionalism”. E-Social Journal, 63, 31-33.】
- 王真麗（2005）。生活課程：理論與實務。臺北市：高等教育。 【Wang, Z.-L. (2005). Life-curriculum: Theory and practice. Taipei, Taiwan: Higher Education.】
- 吳明清（2006）。讓專業成為教育改革動力。台灣教育，637，24-29。doi:10.6395/TER.200602. 0024 【Wu, M.-Q. (2006). Turn professionalism into motivation for education reform. Taiwan Education Review, 637, 24-29. doi:10.6395/TER.200602.0024】
- 吳清山（2010）。師資培育研究。臺北市：高等教育。 【Wu, Q.-S. (2010). Research in teacher education. Taipei, Taiwan: Higher Education.】
- 吳璧純（2008）。找回統整的生活課程：九年一貫生活課程研修及97生活課網的特色。教育研究月刊，175，22-34。 【Wu, B.-C. (2008). Rediscovering the integrated life curricula: A study of the grade 1-9 curriculum and the features of life curricula in 2008. Journal of Education Research, 175, 22-34.】
» More
- 丁增銓（2007）。由「教師專業」談「精進教學能力」。網路社會學通訊期刊，63，31-33。 【Ding, Z.-Q. (2007). Discussing “teaching skill improvement” through “teacher professionalism”. E-Social Journal, 63, 31-33.】
- 王真麗（2005）。生活課程：理論與實務。臺北市：高等教育。 【Wang, Z.-L. (2005). Life-curriculum: Theory and practice. Taipei, Taiwan: Higher Education.】
- 吳明清（2006）。讓專業成為教育改革動力。台灣教育，637，24-29。doi:10.6395/TER.200602. 0024 【Wu, M.-Q. (2006). Turn professionalism into motivation for education reform. Taiwan Education Review, 637, 24-29. doi:10.6395/TER.200602.0024】
- 吳清山（2010）。師資培育研究。臺北市：高等教育。 【Wu, Q.-S. (2010). Research in teacher education. Taipei, Taiwan: Higher Education.】
- 吳璧純（2008）。找回統整的生活課程：九年一貫生活課程研修及97生活課網的特色。教育研究月刊，175，22-34。 【Wu, B.-C. (2008). Rediscovering the integrated life curricula: A study of the grade 1-9 curriculum and the features of life curricula in 2008. Journal of Education Research, 175, 22-34.】
- 呂錘卿（2000）。國民小學教師專業成長的指標及其規劃模式之研究（未出版博士論文）。國立高雄師範大學，高雄市。 【Lu, C.-C. (2000). The criteria and planning model of professional growth for primary school teacher (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). National Kaohsiung Normal University, Kaohsiung, Taiwan.】
- 施良方（1997）。課程理論：課程的基礎、原理與問題。臺北市：麗文文化。 【Shi, L.-F. (1997). Curriculum theory: The foundation, principles, and issues of curricula. Taipei, Taiwan: Liwen.】
- 翁素敏（2011）。國民小學教師專業能力指標建構之研究（未出版碩士論文）。國立政治大學，臺北市。 【Wong, S.-M. (2011). A research on the development of professional indicators for elementary-school teachers (Unpublished master’s thesis). National Chengchi University, Taipei, Taiwan.】
- 張淑娟（2009）。不同教師資格檢定制度對初任教師專業能力影響之研究─以臺北縣市公立高職教師為例（未出版碩士論文）。國立臺灣師範大學，臺北市。 【Chang, S.-C. (2009). A study on the influence of novice teachers’ professional competence trained in different teacher qualification assessment system – With public senior vocational school teachers in Taipei County and City as an example (Unpublished master’s thesis). National Taiwan Normal University, Taipei, Taiwan.】
- 張德銳（2003）。促進教師專業發展的教學檔案。國教新知，49（4），60-68。doi:10.6701/TEEJ. 200306_49(4).0006 【Zhang, D.-R. (2003). Teaching portfolio for promoting professional teacher development. The Elementary Education Journal, 49(4), 60-68. doi:10.6701/TEEJ.200306_49(4).0006】
- 教育部（2000）。國民中小學九年一貫課程生活領域暫行綱要。取自http://teach.eje.edu.tw/ 9CC2/9cc_92.php 【Ministry of Education. (2000). Provisional guidelines for the life curriculum grade 1-9. Retrieved from http://teach. eje.edu.tw/9CC2/9cc_92.php】
- 教育部（2008）。國民中小學九年一貫課程生活領域課程綱要微調草案。取自http://dyna.hcc. edu.tw/campus/data/web/289/files/201205211057301.ppt 【Ministry of Education. (2008). Draft of the life curriculum grade 1-9 guidelines. Retrieved from http://dyna.hcc. edu.tw/campus/data/web/289/files/201205211057301.ppt】
- 教育部（2014）。十二年國民基本教育課程綱要總綱。取自http://www.naer.edu.tw/files/15- 1000-7944,c1174-1.php?Lang=zh-tw 【Ministry of Education. (2014). General curriculum guidelines for 12-year basic education. Retrieved from http://www.naer.edu.tw/files/15-1000-7944,c1174-1.php?Lang=zh-tw】
- 教育部（2016a）。中華民國教師專業標準指引。取自http://ws.moe.edu.tw/001/Upload/8/relfile/ 7834/45668/d4f269e3-96cf-4eac-b038-9a9cda8912f2.pdf 【Ministry of Education. (2016a). Indicators of professional competency of ROC teachers. Retrieved from http://ws. moe.edu.tw/001/Upload/8/relfile/7834/45668/d4f269e3-96cf-4eac-b038-9a9cda8912f2.pdf】
- 教育部（2016b）。高級中等以下學校教師專業發展評鑑規準。取自http://www.cte.fju.edu.tw/ webfile/course4/1050425教育部教專評鑑105年版規準.docx 【Ministry of Education. (2016b). Evaluation standards for professionalism development of teachers at senior high school level and below. Retrieved from http://www.cte.fju.edu.tw/webfile/course4/1050425教育部教專評鑑105年版規準.docx】
- 許珮茜（2013）。國小教師生活課程專業知能與教學態度之研究─以高屏地區為例（未出版碩士論文）。國立屏東教育大學，屏東縣。 【Hsu, P.-C. (2013). The elementary school teachers’ professional knowledge and teaching attitude of life curriculum (Unpublished master’s thesis). National Pingtung University of Education, Pingtung, Taiwan.】
- 陳仲儼、郭俊毅（2010）。教學能力成熟度模式的設計與建立。課程與教學季刊，14（1），141-174。doi:10.6384/CIQ.201101.0142 【Chen, C.-Y., & Kuo, C.-Y. (2010). The design and development of teaching capability maturity model. Curriculum & Instruction Quarterly, 14(1), 141-174. doi:10.6384/CIQ.201101.0142】
- 陳明仁（2013）。國小一般智能資優資源班自然科學相關課程教師專業能力之研究（未出版碩士論文）。國立臺北教育大學，臺北市。doi:10.6344/NTUE.2013.00079 【Chen, M.-J. (2013). A study on the professional competencies of gifted teachers concerned with science course in the elementary schools (Unpublished master’s thesis). National Taipei University of Education, Taipei, Taiwan. doi:10.6344/NTUE.2013.00079】
- 游家政（1996）。得懷術及其在課程研究上的應用。花蓮師院學報，6，1-24。 【You, C.-C. (1996). Delphi technique and it’s application in curriculum study. Journal of National Hualien Teachers College, 6, 1-24.】
- 劉樹貞（2013）。屏東縣國小低年級教師對生活課程實施多元評量的現況與態度之研究（未出版碩士論文）。國立屏東教育大學，屏東縣。 【Liu, S.-C. (2013). A study on the current status and attitude of the implementation of the multiple assessments in life curriculum by the lower-grade elementary school teachers in Pingtung County (Unpublished master’s thesis). National Pingtung University of Education, Pingtung, Taiwan.】
- 潘慧玲、王麗雲、簡茂發、孫志麟、張素貞、張錫勳…蔡濱如（2004a）。國民中小學教師教學專業能力指標之發展。教育研究資訊，12（4），129-168。 【Pan, H.-L., Wan, L.-Y., Chien, M.-F., Sun, C.-L., Chang, S.-C., Chang, H.-H., …Tsai, P.-J. (2004). Developing a professional competence indicator system for teachers in elementary and junior high schools. Educational Research & Information, 12(4), 129-168.】
- 潘慧玲、王麗雲、簡茂發、孫志麟、張素貞、張錫勳…蔡濱如（2004b）。發展國民中小學教師教學專業能力指標之研究（普及版）。取自http://mail.tku.edu.tw/panhlw/doc/teacherin dictor2.pdf 【Pan, H.-L., Wang, L.-Y., Chien, M.-F., Sun, C.-L., Chang, S.-C., Chang, H.-H., … Tsai, P.-J. (2004). Developing a professional competence indicator system for teachers in elementary and junior high schools (universal version). Retrieved from http://mail.tku.edu.tw/panhlw/doc/teacherindictor2.pdf】
- 蔡宜蓁（2011）。生活課程發展之行動研究─以歷程模式和生活能力為主軸（未出版碩士論文）。國立新竹教育大學，新竹市。 【Tsai, Y.-Z. (2011). Action research of life curriculum development based on curriculum process and life skills (Unpublished master’s thesis). National Hsinchu University of Education, Hsinchu, Taiwan.】
- 蔡清田（2011）。素養：課程改革的DNA。臺北市：高等教育。 【Tsai, C.-T. (2011). Competence: DNA of curriculum reform. Taipei, Taiwan: Higher Education.】
- 蔡清田、陳延興（2013）。國民核心素養之課程轉化。課程與教學季刊，16（3），59-78。 【Tsai, C.-T., & Chen, Y.-H. (2013). Curriculum transformation of the key competencies for nationals. Curriculum & Instruction Quarterly, 16(3), 59-78.】
- 簡茂發、李虎雄、黃長司、彭森明、吳清山、吳明清…張敏雪（1997）。中小學教師應具備的基本素質。教育研究資訊，5（3），1-13。 【Chien, M.-F., Lee, H.-S., Huang, C.-S., Peng, S., Wu, C.-S., Wu, M.-C., …Chang, M.-S. (1997). The basic characteristics of teachers at the primary and secondary school. Educational Research & Information, 5(3), 1-13.】
- 饒見維（2003）。教師專業發展：理論與實務。臺北市：五南。 【Rao, J.-W. (2003). Teacher professional development: Theory and practice. Taipei, Taiwan: Wu-Nan Book.】
- Faherty, V. (1979). Continuing social work education: Results of a Delphi survey. Journal of Education for Social Work, 15(1), 12-19. doi:10.1080/00220612.1979.10671539
- Saaty, T. L. (1980). The analytic hierarchy process. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill.