吳汝綸日本教育考察與對晚清學制建立影響程度的再探討
作者:周愚文(國立臺灣師範大學教育學系)
卷期：60卷第3期
日期：2015年9月
頁碼：127-151
DOI：10.6209/JORIES.2015.60(3).05
摘要：
中國教育西化始於晚清，而壬寅及癸卯學制則是創始，主要仿日。制定過程中，過去許多研究認為吳汝綸是主要影響人物之一，他在就任京師大學堂總教習前獲派赴日考察教育4個月，透過參觀、訪談、聽講及資料蒐集，希望全面深入瞭解日本教育的發展與問題。訪問結果除即時陳報管學大臣張百熙及相關人員外，另出版《東遊叢錄》供修訂癸卯學制參考。但經本研究再考察發現，因人在日本考察、返國後朝局不利及病逝等因素，故他未能直接參與規劃、引導方向，以致主政人員在設計學制時，仍只是複製日本制度而已。
關鍵詞：日本教育、吳汝綸、東遊叢錄、教育考察、晚清學制
《詳全文》
參考文獻：
- 丁鴻臣（2004）。遊歷日本視察兵制學制日記。載於王寶平（主編），晚清東遊日記匯編2：日本軍事考察記（pp. 353-384）。上海市：上海古籍。【Ting, H.-C. (2004). A diary of inspecting the military and educational systems in Japan. In B.-P. Wang (Ed.), A collection of inspecting diaries in Japan in late Ch’ing II: Records of inspecting military system in Japan (pp. 353-384). Shanghai, China: Shanghai Guji.】
- 王炳照（主編）（1994）。中國近代教育史。臺北市：五南。【Wang, B.-C. (Ed.). (1994). A history of modern education in China. Taipei, Taiwan: Wu-Nan Book.】
- 王鳴（2000）。吳汝綸的日本教育視察。河北師範大學學報（教育科學版），2（2），35-38。【Wang, M. (2000). Ju-Lun Wu’s inspection on Japanese education. Journal of Hebei Normal University (Educational Science), 2(2), 35-38.】
- 田正平（1996）。留學生與中國教育近代化。廣州市：廣東教育。【Tian, Z.-P. (1996). Oversea students and educational modernization in China. Guangzhou, China: Guangdong Education.】
- 任達（2006）。新政革命與日本：中國1898-1912。南京市：江蘇教育。【Ren, D. (2006). New political reform and Japan: China 1898-1912. Nanjing, China: Jiangsu Education.】
» 展開更多
- 丁鴻臣（2004）。遊歷日本視察兵制學制日記。載於王寶平（主編），晚清東遊日記匯編2：日本軍事考察記（pp. 353-384）。上海市：上海古籍。【Ting, H.-C. (2004). A diary of inspecting the military and educational systems in Japan. In B.-P. Wang (Ed.), A collection of inspecting diaries in Japan in late Ch’ing II: Records of inspecting military system in Japan (pp. 353-384). Shanghai, China: Shanghai Guji.】
- 王炳照（主編）（1994）。中國近代教育史。臺北市：五南。【Wang, B.-C. (Ed.). (1994). A history of modern education in China. Taipei, Taiwan: Wu-Nan Book.】
- 王鳴（2000）。吳汝綸的日本教育視察。河北師範大學學報（教育科學版），2（2），35-38。【Wang, M. (2000). Ju-Lun Wu’s inspection on Japanese education. Journal of Hebei Normal University (Educational Science), 2(2), 35-38.】
- 田正平（1996）。留學生與中國教育近代化。廣州市：廣東教育。【Tian, Z.-P. (1996). Oversea students and educational modernization in China. Guangzhou, China: Guangdong Education.】
- 任達（2006）。新政革命與日本：中國1898-1912。南京市：江蘇教育。【Ren, D. (2006). New political reform and Japan: China 1898-1912. Nanjing, China: Jiangsu Education.】
- 何如璋（1985）。使東述略。載於鍾叔河（編），走向世界叢書III：甲午以前日本游記五種（pp. 85-108）。長沙市：岳麓書社。【Ho, J.-C. (1985). A brief record of envoy in Japan. In S.-H. Zung (Ed.), From east to west: Chinese travelers before 1911 III (pp. 85-108). Changsha, China: Yuelu.】
- 吳汝綸（2002a）。尺牘。載於施培毅、徐壽凱（校點），吳汝綸全集（第三冊）（pp. 1-625）。合肥市：黃山書社。【Wu, J.-L. (2002a). Letters. In P.-I. Shin & S.-K. Xu (Collated), A collected works of Ju-Lun Wu (Vol. III, pp. 1-625). Hefei, China: Huang-shan.】
- 吳汝綸（2002b）。東遊叢錄。載於施培毅、徐壽凱（校點），吳汝綸全集（第三冊）（pp. 656-819）。合肥市：黃山書社。【Wu, J.-L. (2002b). Collected records of visiting Japan. In P.-I. Shin & S.-K. Xu (Collated), A collected works of Ju-Lun Wu (Vol. III, pp. 656-819). Hefei, China: Huang-shan.】
- 吳汝綸（2002c）。日記。載於施培毅、徐壽凱（校點），吳汝綸全集（第四冊）（pp. 1-1125）。合肥市：黃山書社。【Wu, J.-L. (2002c). Diary. In P.-I. Shin & S.-K. Xu (Collated), A collected works of Ju-Lun Wu (Vol. IV, pp. 1-1125). Hefei, China: Huang-shan.】
- 吳汝綸（2002d）。吳汝綸全集（第一冊）。合肥市：黃山書社。【Wu, J.-L. (2002d). A collected works of Ju-Lun Wu (I). Hefei, China: Huang-shan.】
- 吳闓生（2002）。先府君事略。載於施培毅、徐壽凱（校點），吳汝綸全集（第四冊）（pp. 1157-1162）。合肥市：黃山書社。【Wu, K.-S. (2002). A brief biography of my father. In P.-I. Shin & S.-K. Xu (Collated), A collected works of Ju-Lun Wu (Vol. IV, pp. 1157-1162). Hefei, China: Huang-shan.】
- 呂順長（2012）。清末中日教育文化交流之研究。北京市：商務。【Lü, S.-C. (2012). A study in educational and culture exchange between China and Japan in late Ch’ing. Beijing, China: Shang-wu.】
- 呂順長（2014）。呉汝綸日本教育視察の筆談記録（訳注）。四天王寺大學紀要，57，371-387。【Lü, S.-C. (2014). Records of conferring in writing of Ju-Lun Wu inspecting on Japanese education (translation and notes). Shitennoji University Bulletin, 57, 371-387.】
- 呂順長（編著）（1999）。晚清中國人日本考察記集成：教育考察記。杭州市：杭州大學。【Lü, S.-C. (Ed.). (1999). Collected records of Chinese inspecting Japan in late Ch’ing I: Education. Hangzhou, China: Hangzhou University.】
- 李景濂（2002）。吳摯甫先生傳。載於施培毅、徐壽凱（校點），吳汝綸全集（第四冊）（pp. 1126-1138）。合肥市：黃山書社。【Li, C.-L. (2002). A biography of Mr. Chi-Fu Wu. In P.-I. Shin & S.-K. Xu (Collated), A collected works of Ju-Lun Wu (Vol. IV, pp. 1126-1138). Hefei, China: Huang-shan.】
- 汪婉（1998）。清末中囯対日教育視察の研究。東京都：汲古書院。【Wang, W. (1998). A study in Chinese inspection to Japanese education in late Ch’ing. Tokyo, Japan: Kyuko.】
- 沈翊清（1999）。東遊日記。載於呂順長（編著），晚清中國人日本考察記集成：教育考察記上（pp. 121-161）。杭州市：杭州大學。【Shen, I.-C. (1999). Visiting Japan diary. In. S.-C. Lü (Ed.), Collected records of Chinese inspecting Japan in late Ch’ing I: Education (pp. 121-161). Hangzhou, China: Hangzhou University.】
- 周正雲（輯校）（2010）。晚清湖南新政奏摺章程選編。長沙市：岳麓書社。【Zhou, Z.-Y. (Ed.). (2010). A selected works of the reports to thrones for political reform in Hunan in late Ch’ing. Changsha, China: Yuelu.】
- 周愚文（2015）。羅振玉日本教育考察與晚清學制制定的關係。教育研究集刊，61（1），1-33。dio:10.3966/10288708201536101001【Chou, Y.-W. (2015). Chen-Yu Lo’ inspection on Japanese education and the drafting of school systems in late Ch’ing. Bulletin of Education Research, 61(1), 1-33. dio:10.3966/10288708201536101001】
- 周慧（2004）。吳汝綸與清末學制。寧波大學學報（教育科學版），26（5），48-51。【Zhou, H. (2004). Ju-Lun Wu and school system in late Ch’ing. Journal of Ningbo University (Educational Science), 26(5), 48-51.】
- 阿部洋（1990）。向日本借鑑：中國最早的近代化教育體制。載於許美德、巴斯蒂（主編），中外比較教育史（pp. 90-119）。上海市：上海人民。【Abe, H. (1990). Borrowing from Japan: The earliest modern educational system in China. In R. Hayhoe & M. Bastid (Eds.), China education and the industrial world: Studies in cultural transfer (pp. 90-119). Shanghai, China: Shanghai People.】
- 姚永概（2002）。吳摯甫先生行狀。載於施培毅、徐壽凱（校點），吳汝綸全集（第四冊）（pp. 1144-1147）。合肥市：黃山書社。【Yao, Y.-K. (2002). A brief biography of Chih-Fu Wu. In P.-I. Shin & S.-K. Xu (Collated), A collected works of Ju-Lun Wu works (Vol. IV, pp. 1144-1147). Hefei, China: Huang-shan.】
- 姚錫光（1999）。東瀛學校舉概。載於呂順長（編著），晚清中國人日本考察記集成：教育考察記上（pp. 1-22）。杭州市：杭州大學。【Yao, H.-K. (1999). Introduction to Japanese schools. In. S.-C. Lü (Ed.), Collected records of Chinese inspecting Japan in late Ch’ing I: Education (pp. 1-22). Hangzhou, China: Hangzhou University.】
- 施培毅（1995）。我國近代教育先驅吳汝綸。江淮論壇，1，86-96。【Shih, P.-I. (1995). Modern educational pioneer Ju-Lun Wu. Yangtze-Huai Forum, 1, 86-96.】
- 胡國勇（1996）。第二章壬寅學制（1902年學制）和癸卯學制（1904年學制）。載於錢曼倩、金林祥（主編），中國近代學制比較研究（pp. 50-127）。廣州市：廣東教育。【Hu, G.-Y. (1996). Chapter II: Ren-yin and Kuei-mao school systems. In M.-Q. Qian & L.-X. Jin (Eds.), A comparative study in school system in modern China (pp. 50-127). Guangzhou, China: Guangdong Education.】
- 徐宗林、周愚文（1997）。教育史。臺北市：五南。【Hsu, C.-L., & Chou, Y.-W. (1997). History of education. Taipei, Taiwan: Wu-Nan Book.】
- 徐壽凱（2005）。吳汝綸在我國近代教育中定位問題之我見。安徽教育學院學報，23（1），94-96。【Xu, S.-K. (2005). My personal view on the reappraisal of the role of Wu Ru-Lun in modern Chinese education. Journal of Anhui Institute of Education, 23(1), 94-96.】
- 張大鏞（1999）。日本各校記略。載於呂順長（編著），晚清中國人日本考察記集成：教育考察記上（pp. 23-56）。杭州市：杭州大學。【Chang, T.-Y. (1999). Brief record of Japanese schools. In. S.-C. Lü (Ed.), Collected records of Chinese inspecting Japan in late Ch’ing I: Education (pp. 23-56). Hangzhou, China: Hangzhou University.】
- 張之洞（1991）。張之洞致張冶秋尚書。載於璩鑫圭、唐良炎（編），中國近代教育史資料匯編（學制演變）（pp. 135-136）。上海市：上海教育。【Chang, C.-T. (1991). Letter from Chih-Tung Chang to minister Yeh-Chiu Chang. In S.-G. Cui & L.-Y. Tan (Eds.), Collected sources of modern history of Chinese education: The change of school systems (pp. 135-136). Shanghai, China: Shanghai Education.】
- 張百熙（2008）。張百熙集。長沙市：岳麓書社。【Chang, P.-H. (2008). A collected works of Pai-Hsi Chang. Changsha, China: Yuelu.】
- 郭立志（編）（1972）。桐城吳先生（汝綸）年譜。臺北市：文海。【Kuo, L.-C. (Ed.). (1972). A chronological biography of Mr. Ju-Lun Wu at T’ung-ch’en. Taipei, Taiwan: Wen-hai.】
- 傅雲龍（2003）。遊歷日本圖經。上海市：上海古籍。【Fu, Y.-L. (2003). Visiting Japan record. Shanghai, China: Shanghai Guji.】
- 黃遵憲（1991）。與某總教習。載於鄭海麟、張偉雄（編校），黃遵憲文集（p. 219）。京都市：中文。【Huang, T.-H. (1991). To vice-chancellor. In H.-L. Cheng & W.-H. Chang (Eds.), A collected works of Tsun-Hsien Huang (p. 219). Kyoto, Japan: Chinese Press.】
- 黃遵憲（2005）。日本國志。載於陳錚（編），黃遵憲全集下（pp. 817-1564）。北京市：中華。【Huang, T.-H. (2005). A general history of Japan. In C. Chen (Ed.), A collected works of Tsun-Hsien Huang II (pp. 817-1564). Beijing, China: Zhonghua.】
- 楊國賜（1975）。比較教育方法論。臺北市：正中。【Yang, K.-T. (1975). The methodology of comparative education. Taipei, Taiwan: Cheng Chung.】
- 熊賢君（2006）。中國近代義務教育研究。武漢市：華中師大。【Xiong, X.-J. (2006). A study in compulsory education in modern China. Wuhan, China: Central China Normal University.】
- 趙建民（1999）。吳汝綸赴日考察與中國學制的現代化。史料研究，5，40-46。【Zhao, J.-M. (1999). Ju-Lun Wu’s inspection on Japan and the modernization of school system in China. Historical Sources Studies, 5, 40-46.】
- 衛道治（主編）（1998）。中外教育交流史。長沙市：湖南教育。【Wei, D.-J. (Ed.). (1998). A history of educational exchange between China and foreign countries. Changsha, China: Hunan Education.】
- 鄭德新（2009）。中國教育近代化的起步：以吳汝綸教育思想和實踐為中心的考察。合肥市：安徽教育。【Zheng, D.-X. (2009). The beginning of educational modernization in China: An inquiry of the educational thought and practice of Ju-Lun Wu. Hefei, China: Anhui Education.】
- 劉虹（2009）。吳汝綸與張之洞課程觀之芻議。湖南大學學報（社科版），23（1），38-43。【Liu, H. (2009). A brief study on Wu Rulun and Zhang Zhidong’s curricular opinions. Journal of Hunan University (Social Sciences), 23(1), 38-43.】
- 鍾叔河（2000）。走向世界－近代中國知識分子考察西方的歷史。北京市：中華。【Zung, S.-H. (2000). Marching toward the world: A history of modern Chinese intellectuals to inspect the west. Beijing, China: Zhonghua.】
- 羅振玉（2010a）。扶桑兩月記。載於羅振玉、羅繼祖、王同策（主編），羅振玉學術論著集（第十一集）（pp. 93-125）。上海市：上海古籍。【Lo, C.-Y. (2010a). Two months’ record in Japan. In C.-Y. Lo, C.-T. Lo, & T.-C. Wang (Eds.), A collected works of Chen-Yu Lo (Vol. XI, pp. 93-125). Shanghai, China: Shanghai Guji.】
- 羅振玉（2010b）。永豐鄉人行年錄。載於羅振玉、羅繼祖、王同策（主編），羅振玉學術論著集（第十二集）（pp. 339-484）。上海市：上海古籍。【Lo, C.-Y. (2010b). Yun-feng-hsien-jen-hsiang-nien-lu. In C.-Y. Lo, C.-T. Lo, & T.-C. Wang (Eds.), A collected works of Chen-Yu Lo (Vol. XII, pp. 339-484). Shanghai, China: Shanghai Guji.】
- 顧厚焜（2002）。日本新政考。載於劉雨珍、孫雪梅（編），日本政法考察記（pp. 1-38）。上海市：上海古籍。【Ku, H.-K. (2002). A study in political reform in Japan. In Y.-J. Liu & S.-M. Sun (Eds.), Collected records of Chinese inspecting Japanese politics and law in late Ch’ing (pp. 1-38). Shanghai, China: Shanghai Guji.】
Journal directory listing - Volume 60 (2015) - Journal of Research in Education Sciences【60(3)】September
Master Ju-Lun Wu’s Inspection of Japanese Education and Reevaluation of Its Influence on the Drafting of School Systems in the Late Ch’ing Period
Author: Yu-Wen Chou(Department of Education, National Taiwan Normal University)
Vol.&No.：Vol. 60, No. 3
Date：September 2015
Pages：127-151
DOI：10.6209/JORIES.2015.60(3).05
Abstract：
The modernization of Chinese education began from the late Ch’ing period, and the 1902 Ren-yin and 1904 Kuei-mao school systems marked the beginning of the modernization of Chinese education, which borrowed from Japanese education. Numerous studies have claimed that master Ju-Lun Wu was one of the key figures, before he inaugurated the vice-chancellor of Imperial Capital University, who inspected Japanese education over 4 months. He inquired into the development and problems of Japanese education by inspecting schools and universities; discussing with scholars, educators, and officials; listening to lectures; and collecting materials. His findings were reported to Minister Pai-Shi Chang and related staff and his Collected Records of Visiting Japan was published. Although his book became a reference book, this study found that Ju-Lun Wu was not directly involved in drafting school systems for several reasons. Therefore, the 1904 Kuei-mao system remains an uncritical, imitated Japanese school system.
Keywords：Japanese education, Ju-Lun Wu, Collected Records of Visiting Japan, educational inspection, school system